For years, a consent order on a bank's regulatory record functioned as an almost automatic conversation-ender in merger and acquisition discussions. The stigma was decisive, the due diligence brutal, and the appetite from acquirers virtually nonexistent. But as First Internet Bank chief executive David Becker made clear in a recent wide-ranging interview, that calculus has fundamentally shifted — and understanding why reveals something important about the current state of community banking, fintech partnerships, and the compliance infrastructure underpinning both.
The evidence is visible at the deal level. Capital One completed its acquisition of Discover despite the target's regulatory history. HomeTrust agreed to acquire Blue Ridge, itself carrying a compliance record. First Financial moved forward with a deal for Finward under similar circumstances. These transactions signal a maturing of market judgment: acquirers are increasingly willing to price in a consent order rather than walk away from an otherwise sound institution, provided the underlying issues are genuinely being addressed. The order, in this new framing, becomes a negotiating variable rather than a veto.
What is driving the volume of recent consent orders in the first place, however, deserves equal attention. Becker's diagnosis is pointed. A significant share of orders now on community bank balance sheets trace directly to Bank Secrecy Act (BSA) and Anti-Money Laundering (AML) compliance failures that emerged from fintech partnerships. The pattern is consistent: a community bank enters a banking-as-a-service arrangement or similar fintech collaboration, and there is an implicit — sometimes explicit — assumption that the fintech partner is responsible for the compliance infrastructure. Monitoring, transaction surveillance, know-your-customer protocols — the bank believed the technology provider had it covered.
Examiners, it turns out, see the arrangement differently. Under longstanding regulatory doctrine, the bank holds ultimate accountability for BSA/AML compliance, regardless of what contractual arrangements exist with a third party. When examiners reviewed these partnerships and found the compliance work had effectively been delegated without adequate bank oversight or verification, the resulting gap was the bank's problem to own. Consent orders followed. The pattern has repeated itself across enough institutions that it now constitutes a recognizable systemic issue in community banking's fintech chapter — one with real consequences for bank valuations, executive bandwidth, and strategic flexibility.
The lesson is structural rather than anecdotal. Banks that entered the embedded finance and banking-as-a-service era attracted by revenue diversification and technology leverage often underestimated the compliance due diligence those arrangements demanded. The fintech partner might have built sophisticated customer-facing products, but transaction monitoring, suspicious activity reporting, and customer risk scoring still required rigorous bank-side governance. Where that governance was absent or insufficient, regulators responded accordingly. Becker's framing situates this not as isolated mismanagement but as a sector-wide misreading of where compliance ownership actually resided.
Against that backdrop of regulatory remediation, First Internet Bank's work applying Small Business Administration (SBA) loan processing to artificial intelligence (AI) represents the institution's forward-looking counterpoint. SBA lending is notoriously documentation-intensive, with underwriting requirements, eligibility determinations, and government guarantee processes that generate substantial manual workload. For a digitally native institution like First Internet Bank — which was built from the outset without branch infrastructure and operates with an efficiency orientation — applying AI tooling to compress that workflow is a natural strategic extension. The goal is both operational and competitive: faster decisioning benefits small business borrowers who often need capital on a timeline that traditional SBA processing has historically struggled to meet.
The convergence of these two threads — consent order rehabilitation and AI-driven lending innovation — captures the particular pressure point that many mid-tier and community banks occupy today. They are simultaneously managing the compliance residue of a partnership model that expanded faster than governance frameworks could accommodate, while also being expected to deploy technology that keeps them relevant against larger institutions and pure-play fintech lenders with superior technology budgets. Doing both at once, without sacrificing one for the other, is the operational challenge that Becker's remarks implicitly frame.
What This Means for the Industry
The normalization of consent-order-carrying institutions as viable acquisition targets is not an invitation to treat compliance failures casually. It reflects, rather, a market acknowledging that the fintech partnership boom generated compliance overhang broadly enough that stigmatizing every affected institution would strip the M&A market of viable community bank targets at the precise moment consolidation pressure is highest. Acquirers are doing harder analytical work: distinguishing between banks with genuine remediation underway and those where the compliance culture remains broken. Meanwhile, Becker's AI push on SBA loans points to where differentiation will increasingly be built — not in branching strategy or deposit pricing alone, but in the ability to automate complex, government-adjacent lending workflows that remain stubbornly manual across much of the industry. Community banks that resolve their regulatory overhangs quickly and redirect that executive attention toward technology deployment will be positioned most favorably in the consolidation wave ahead.
Written by the editorial team — independent journalism powered by Codego Press.