On November 16, 2026, European Central Bank Executive Board member Frank Elderson turned the institution's supervisory lens toward a constituency that rarely commands headline attention: Europe's smaller banks. In remarks published under the title "Smart supervision for small banks," Elderson signalled that the ECB is actively reconsidering how proportionality, efficiency, and risk-sensitivity should govern oversight of institutions that, while individually modest in balance-sheet size, collectively form the capillary system of European credit.
The timing is not incidental. European banking supervision has spent the better part of a decade consolidating around the largest, most systemically significant institutions — the so-called significant institutions (SIs) that fall under the ECB's direct supervisory jurisdiction within the Single Supervisory Mechanism (SSM). Yet the broader European banking landscape is dominated numerically by less significant institutions (LSIs): community lenders, cooperative banks, savings banks, and regional credit institutions that serve local economies from rural Portugal to central Germany. These entities are supervised primarily by national competent authorities, but the ECB sets the overarching framework and retains oversight of the oversight.
The challenge Elderson's intervention implicitly acknowledges is a structural one. Supervisory frameworks designed for globally active, systemically important banks impose compliance costs — in reporting, in governance requirements, in internal model validation — that can be disproportionate when applied wholesale to a regional cooperative lender with a €500 million balance sheet. The Basel III finalisation package, now being transposed into European law through the Capital Requirements Regulation (CRR3) and Capital Requirements Directive (CRD6), has already attempted to embed proportionality provisions for smaller institutions. But regulatory proportionality on paper and proportionality in supervisory practice are not always the same thing.
Elderson's framing of "smart supervision" is worth unpacking as an analytical category. The word "smart" in a regulatory context typically gestures toward three things: the use of data and technology to focus supervisory resources on genuine risk rather than procedural box-ticking; the calibration of requirements to the actual risk profile of the institution being supervised; and the recognition that effective supervision of smaller banks requires different skills and tools than supervising a global systemically important bank (G-SIB). All three dimensions matter enormously for the LSI population, which is diverse enough to defy simple categorisation.
The stakes extend beyond administrative efficiency. Small and medium-sized banks in the European Union collectively provide a substantial share of credit to small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) — the backbone of employment across member states. When supervisory burdens become heavy enough to erode profitability or accelerate consolidation among smaller lenders, the consequences ripple through real economies. Local credit markets can lose diversity and competitive pressure. Businesses that do not meet the credit appetite of large universal banks may find financing harder to access. These are not abstract concerns: the decline of community banking in the United States over the past three decades offers a cautionary parallel that European policymakers have noted with concern.
At the same time, smart supervision cannot mean light supervision. The collapse of smaller regional banks — whether through credit concentration risk, governance failures, or inadequate liquidity buffers — can impose real costs on depositors and on national deposit guarantee schemes. The ECB's supervisory credibility depends on demonstrating that proportionality does not become a euphemism for laxity. Elderson and his colleagues must navigate that tension explicitly and transparently, which is precisely why a public intervention on the topic carries institutional weight beyond the immediate policy moment.
There is also a technological dimension that sits beneath Elderson's framing. The ECB and national supervisors have been investing in supervisory technology (SupTech) tools that allow for more granular, real-time monitoring of institutional data without multiplying the reporting burden on supervised entities. If those tools mature as intended, they could genuinely change the cost-risk calculus of supervising smaller banks — enabling more targeted, risk-based intervention rather than cyclical, process-heavy examinations. Whether that promise translates into practice across the patchwork of national supervisory authorities that make up the SSM's LSI infrastructure remains an open question.
What This Means for the Industry
Elderson's focus on smaller banks sends a clear signal to national competent authorities, industry associations, and LSI management teams alike: the ECB is paying attention to whether the architecture of European supervision is fit for purpose across the full spectrum of the banking sector, not merely its largest nodes. For smaller institutions, this represents an opportunity to engage constructively with the supervisory dialogue — to make the case for proportionate treatment backed by evidence of sound governance and risk management. For regulators, it is a reminder that supervisory effectiveness is not measured solely by the comprehensiveness of requirements imposed, but by the accuracy with which those requirements match the actual risk landscape. The coming months will reveal whether "smart supervision" evolves from an aspirational phrase into a concrete supervisory programme with measurable outcomes for Europe's diverse community of smaller banks.
Written by the editorial team — independent journalism powered by Codego Press.